{"id":"discovery-beyond-mirroring","title":"Discovering context beyond the current frame","regions":["shared-inquiry","language-and-experience"],"question":"How can a model help discover an unseen context without merely mirroring its current interlocutor?","formulation":"A recurring demand is for an interpretation that moves beyond recycling the currently supplied concepts. Another question separates recognizing a text’s intention from merely recognizing familiar or incoherent language.","representations":[{"name":"Interpretation within a supplied frame","affords":"Maintains continuity and relevance.","loses":"Can merely mirror the vocabulary already available.","epistemic_kind":"reconstruction"},{"name":"A proposed alternative context","affords":"Can expose another question or explanation.","loses":"Novel context may be unsupported projection rather than discovery.","epistemic_kind":"reconstruction"}],"tension":"Going beyond the frame should create a challengeable hypothesis, not an invented claim about a person’s hidden intention.","challenge":"What evidence would favor a new context over a fluent repetition of the existing one?","development":"independent_branch","epistemic_kind":"reconstruction","evidence":["basis-discovery-beyond-mirroring"],"next_move":{"text":"Ask for two competing context hypotheses and specify an observation that could disconfirm each.","epistemic_kind":"model_proposed"},"open_questions":["How can a model help discover an unseen context without merely mirroring its current interlocutor?","What evidence would favor a new context over a fluent repetition of the existing one?"],"formal_status":"open_problem","version":1,"content_hash":"3fd2ed0f4b9bfce7ff04ec30347321539dd16edeba696975ddb19a356952e19e"}