{"id":"exploration-before-implementation","title":"Considering a problem is different from implementing a policy","regions":["shared-inquiry","normative-change"],"question":"Can unresolved policy and moral-plurality problems become generative training material without being mistaken for endorsed implementation?","formulation":"Comparative interpretation and the generation of training examples are possible uses of open normative problems. Whether to implement a particular policy remains a separate judgment.","representations":[{"name":"An unresolved problem presented for interpretation","affords":"Permits critique without endorsement.","loses":"A fluent response may prematurely close the question.","epistemic_kind":"reconstruction"},{"name":"Generated examples for learning or evaluation","affords":"Makes implications more concrete.","loses":"Synthetic examples may normalize the generator’s favored solution.","epistemic_kind":"reconstruction"}],"tension":"Expanding examples can enrich a problem or turn its unresolved tensions into a repeated doctrine.","challenge":"Can a training example preserve a real disagreement and an implementation decision that remains open?","development":"active","epistemic_kind":"reconstruction","evidence":["basis-exploration-before-implementation"],"next_move":{"text":"Generate contrasting examples with explicit objections and compare whether readers still recognize the unresolved issue.","epistemic_kind":"model_proposed"},"open_questions":["Can unresolved policy and moral-plurality problems become generative training material without being mistaken for endorsed implementation?","Can a training example preserve a real disagreement and an implementation decision that remains open?"],"formal_status":"open_problem","version":1,"content_hash":"41eaef584aaab1eba6618119bbf0c1d1b74fff0d5c91b26bc8eb43efcddfa206"}